Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?

deviantART

:woohoo:
 

Godwin's Law Proposal

Thu Apr 24, 2008, 5:44 PM
  • Mood: Angsty


Affiliated Groups and Clubs
FoxFire Studios of Saint Louis
Lost Boy Found Novel
Scarlet PI Site





Godwin's Law [link] is a popular law strongly enforced in many online forums. In the official listing, the law states as thus:

"As a Usenet discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches one."

In practice today, the concept is that, in any online debate that gets somewhat heated, the chances that someone calls someone a Nazi (Or some resemblance thereof) increases. When this happens, all debate is considered over and the person who invoked the evil German regime is considered to have lost said debate.

In this presidential race of 2008, I call that the law be expanded: "As any debate grows longer, the probability of someone being called a racist approaches 100%. When this happens, all debate stops and the party accusing racism automatically loses."

Of course, that means that there are huge sectors of the Left, and some of the Right, should automatically be excused from all political debate . . . but then again, that might not be a bad thing.

(NOTE: For this version of Godwin's Law to be invoked, someone must be called a racist directly. Identifying actions and words instead gets a pass.)

What say you?




Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconkriegsaffeno9:
Nitpick: it's Godwin's law, not Goodwin's.

--
True, the shield might block the occasional sword blow. However... “If I were to pick up this cowering-plate, I would have to put down my second sword,” a Scotsman thinks. “And surely that is madness.” -- Team Fortress 2
:icondaveykinsfoxfire:
I'll edit it.

--
David FoxFire of FoxFire Studios
[link]
:iconbagshotrow:
Sounds like something a racist would say

--
I invited you to the OWN ZONE :flame:

WE HAVE T'CHANNNGE
TIME TO TURN THE PANNNGE
:icondaveykinsfoxfire:
Godwin's Law. You lose. Have a nice day.

--
David FoxFire of FoxFire Studios
[link]
:iconbagshotrow:
Better watch out, my skin is as black as the heart that beats underneath

gonna take your lunch money

--
I invited you to the OWN ZONE :flame:

WE HAVE T'CHANNNGE
TIME TO TURN THE PANNNGE
:iconbagshotrow:
And come to think of it, you're confusing the term "law" as an enforced legal mandate with the term "law" as an observed scientific principle. Godwin's law is the latter.

Is this still about your history teacher?

--
I invited you to the OWN ZONE :flame:

WE HAVE T'CHANNNGE
TIME TO TURN THE PANNNGE
:icondaveykinsfoxfire:
For the record, no. That's long gone.

This is about the 2008 Presidential Election, and the overtendency for things to get racially heated because of Barack Obama's good chances in it. You've probably heard of the race card. There's people who are playing the race _deck_, and I can give examples on both sides. Personally, most of us saw this coming a mile away.

That's the reason why I'm suggesting amending Godwin's Law to include terms that are passed around more prevalently than "Nazi," and sound just as offensive as any racial slur.

In fact, some people are using 'racist' as such a slur. At least it sounds like it to me.

--
David FoxFire of FoxFire Studios
[link]
:iconbagshotrow:
what if someone actually IS racist

--
I invited you to the OWN ZONE :flame:

WE HAVE T'CHANNNGE
TIME TO TURN THE PANNNGE
:icongargu:
"When this happens, all debate is considered over and the person who invoked the evil German regime is considered to have lost said debate."

No.

Journal History

Who would win in a fight. 

42%
10 deviants said God
33%
8 deviants said Trick Question: Ezio is God.
13%
3 deviants said Desmond
8%
2 deviants said Altaïr (Assassin's Creed 1)
4%
1 deviant said Ezio (Assassin's Creed 2)

ShoutBoard

To Be Continued

Forum

There are no threads yet!

ShoutBoard

Check out Lost Boy Found at my Web Site [link] , and you can even help me with the edits. The book is open source.

Site Map